Raniero Busco nel 1990 |
Raniero Busco nel 2010 |
Le caratteristiche dentali and type of signs that would leave the act of Busco bite to bite were analyzed according to the procedures suggested by the American Board of Forensic Odontology, the body that certifies forensic dentists in the USA. I would point out as colleagues Pretty and Bowers have shown recently that the analysis of a human bite can lead to conflicting technical advice when the degree of subjectivity of the expert is predominant and the available data derived from technical surveys are insufficient in quantity or quality . (Emilio Nuzzolese)
Pretty's ladder is a tool for defining the significance an actual or alleged injury to bite.
This scale is divided into four points that show many signs derived from a bite.
In paragraphs 1 and 2 is of low significance because there is law in the second dental arch and the wounds have elements in itself insufficient to state with certainty the nature of this lesion.
In paragraphs 3 and 4 have a high forensic significance for the presence of both the signs of the arches, visible and recognizable even to non-expert eyes (think of the sign "clock" that was made by children ).
Dr. Pretty, interviewed by Dr. Emilio Nuzzolese (expert appointed by the defense of the accused) with whom he collaborated with some work, saw photos of the left nipple of Simonetta Cesaroni and defined the two signs found (the alleged "bite") of low significance, giving the lesion 2 in the scale devised by himself, became a reference point in forensic dentistry for the classification of injury from the bite. As reiterated by the same Nuzzolese during the fifteenth day of the trial for the crime against Raniero Busco Via Poma, data uncertain and hypothetical cause of false diagnosis, being susceptible to considerations and interpretations e conclusioni soggettive e non oggettive.
Si pensi solo che il Pm Roberto Cavallone, nel dare il mandato ai periti dell'accusa di effettuare una perizia in merito alla valutazione di compatibilità riguardo la lesione con la dentatura di Raniero, chiese di “ mostrare una particolare attenzione all'arcata inferiore di Busco ”. Così è stato fatto. E così si è conclusa anche l'attribuzione di compatibilità tra la ferita e la dentatura dell'imputato. "Al di là di ogni ragionevole dubbio".
di Roberta Milletarì
0 comments:
Post a Comment